

When taking out an insurance policy for items such as caravans, homes, or contents, you will often be faced with two primary options for cover: new for old and market value. These terms dictate how your items are valued and replaced in the event of a claim. It's essential to know the difference between the two to make an informed decision about the best type of cover for your needs.
New for old cover means that if your insured items are damaged or destroyed, the insurance company will replace them with new ones, regardless of the age or condition of the damaged items before the loss occurred. This kind of policy aims to put you in a similar position to where you were before the loss, without considering depreciation.
Market value cover, on the other hand, takes into account the item's current market value at the time of the loss. This means you are compensated based on the item's worth considering its age, wear and tear, and any depreciation. It reflects what you would get if you sold the item second-hand just before the loss occurred.
The difference in premiums between new for old and market value cover can be significant. Since new for old policies provide a higher level of protection, they often come with higher premiums. Market value policies may be more budget-friendly, but they can result in much lower payouts after a claim.
You might choose new for old cover if:

Market value cover might be more appropriate if:
When deciding which cover to opt for, think about the following:
Remember that some insurers might only offer one type of cover, whilst others will give you the choice.
The type of cover you choose will significantly impact the claims process and the outcome. With new for old, you'll typically be able to replace your items swiftly and get back to normal more quickly. Market value claims might involve more negotiation to establish the item's value and could result in you being out of pocket if you wish to purchase new replacements.
Certain items may not be eligible for new for old cover, or there may be specific conditions attached. For example:
Always check the terms and conditions of your policy to understand what is covered and under what circumstances.
The difference between new for old and market value cover is a critical consideration when taking out an insurance policy. The choice will affect not only your premiums but also the amount you can claim, and the replacement of your items in the event of a claim. It's vital to assess the value of your possessions, your financial situation, and your willingness to pay higher premiums for more comprehensive protection.
If you're considering insurance options and want to find out which cover type suits your situation best, click the quote button for quotes from a panel of specialist insurance providers. They can help you compare options and secure a policy that provides the right level of protection for you.
Home Is there a 2026 insurance guide? What does it cost? Are there ways of reducing it's cost? Are there common exclusions? Can I lend my van to a friend? Can I use it for foreign holidays? Can I insure one built abroad? Are there different types of policies? How does it differ from car insurance? Are third party risks covered? Can I buy insurance for a stored caravan? How do I choose the best policy? Is insurance mandatory? Shold I get new for old or market value cover? Are public liability risks included? Can I rent my caravan out? Can I insure a self built one? Can I transfer cover between caravans? Is it covered whilst being transported? Can young drivers get insured? Is accidental damage covered? Do I have to use approved security devices? Is theft protection included? Can I travel in Europe? How are valuations calculated? Will a criminal record stop me from buying cover? Will a bad driving record affect my premium? What effect will modifications have? Are the security measures that can lower premiums? Are there age limits for buying a policy? How do I get discounts on the premium? Are awnings covered? How does it's age affect premiums? Do motor movers affect premiums? Can I insure an old one? Is there special insurance for tourers? Should I install a tracking device? Can brokers help me to buy the right policy? Can I insure one for business use? Can multiple ones be insured on a single policy? What are the factors affecting premiums? Are breakdowns covered? What if I go to festivals? Can I pay the premium monthly? Are pets covered? Is storm or flood damage covered? What information must I provide to get a policy? Can I insure one to live in full time? Are there policy excesses I must pay? What should I look for in a policy? Are personal belongings covered? Is water leakage covered? Are there special policies for static vans?